The news we encounter, the order of content and AI responses depend on choices that often remain in the background. Radar Special 10A, From cultural hegemony to algorithmic hegemony, starts with Gramsci to understand how this mediation takes shape, who sets its criteria and what possibilities we have to understand and question it.
From cultural hegemony to algorithmic hegemony
Special Issue 10A | Wednesday 21 October 2026 | Approximately 7 minutes to read
We open an assistant and ask it to explain what is happening. Within seconds, an organised answer arrives, with causes, the words to use and a conclusion. It can truly help us: it makes a difficult subject more accessible and saves us time. But as we follow the reasoning, we rarely see all the choices that made it possible.
This Special follows those choices, from the places where culture takes shape to the systems that now rank content and generate responses. The point is not to imagine a single hidden directing force, but to recognise where concrete power is exercised: deciding which information we encounter, how it is presented to us and which alternatives we can choose.
1. Why return to Gramsci
Schools, newspapers, publishers and everyday conversations help shape what we consider important or reasonable. In the Prison Notebooks, Gramsci studies how political leadership can also consolidate itself through culture and consent. In Notebook 19, paragraph 24, he distinguishes domination from the capacity to exercise intellectual and moral leadership: a distinction that also invites us to look at the relationships and organisations through which ideas gain strength.
Returning to this question in the digital world does not mean attributing a theory of artificial intelligence to Gramsci, or claiming that platforms are implementing a project of his. The comparison serves to examine a function: how some ways of interpreting reality become familiar, while others remain harder to encounter. Understanding this process does not mean approving of it; it allows us to discuss its interests, limits and responsibilities.
2. When the front page changes for each person
A newspaper’s front page presents an identifiable hierarchy, shared by readers of that edition. A personalised content feed, by contrast, can show different orders to different people and change them while it is being used. Building it requires choices about which content to consider and which signals to use to assign priority: this is what we call ranking, or ordering.
The work on YouTube published by Google researchers in 2016 specifically distinguishes the selection of candidate content from its subsequent ranking. It is a historical technical description, which does not provide a complete picture of current systems, but clarifies why the existence of content is not enough to make it visible.
A click can contribute to this selection without giving the person control over the criteria. Someone decides what to measure, how much weight to assign to it and which outcome to pursue. As in the relationship between platforms and the organisation of decisions, power also lies in the possibilities offered by the environment in which we act.
💡 Did you know? — Changing what we see does not always produce the same effect
In an experiment on Facebook during the 2020 US elections, reducing exposure to politically like-minded sources changed the content encountered by 23,377 participants. However, no measurable effects emerged on the eight attitudes examined, including affective polarisation. The result concerns those people, that period and that intervention: it helps distinguish content selection from its possible effects on opinions, without turning a single study into a universal explanation.
3. From ranked content to a generated response
With a language model, another stage changes. The system does not simply line up existing pages: it generates a response. Readers may therefore lose sight of the sources and intermediate choices, especially when the text is clear and convincing. It then becomes essential to be able to trace the cited documents and recognise where the reasoning introduces an interpretation.
Different layers work behind the result. Data contribute to training; examples and evaluations help guide behaviour; product rules establish limits and priorities. The 2022 InstructGPT paper, for example, describes the use of demonstrations and rankings produced by human evaluators in successive training stages. Evaluators’ preferences become part of the process, rather than a comment added at the end.
During use, the context of the request, any documents and information retained by the product also come into play. These distinctions are already central when we ask what really changes when we correct a response. Calling everything “the algorithm” makes it harder to understand who chose what and where intervention is possible.
4. The personal assistant and the boundary of delegated authority
An assistant that can consult an archive offers different help from a chat without documents. It can connect scattered information, retrieve a passage and help us prepare for a decision and reason it through in dialogue. If it also has operational tools, it can perform tasks within the permissions assigned to it. The benefit grows alongside the need to understand which data it can reach and which actions have been authorised.
Imagine asking it for a summary for a project. Consulting that project’s folder can be useful; being able to access other archives as well requires a further, understandable choice. Managing delegated authority requires limited permissions, the ability to revoke them and readable records of operations. And before a proposal is used, the step from a response to a verified result remains.
🧠 Radar Insight — Taking part does not mean deciding
Our texts, evaluations and behaviour can contribute to how a system works. This contribution does not automatically give us the power to change its objectives or rules. To assess how much autonomy we have, we must look at concrete possibilities: knowing the criteria, limiting access, stopping a task and changing tools without losing what we have built.
5. Understanding choices, being able to discuss them
The Digital Services Act, the European regulation on digital services, introduces transparency obligations for recommendation systems and complaint mechanisms for certain platform decisions. These are important possibilities, but they must become understandable and usable: a formal explanation is of little help if it does not make it possible to understand what happened or whom to contact.
The publication of risk assessments and independent audits for very large platforms and search engines also opens up scope for scrutiny. On its own, it does not prove that every problem is solved; it allows researchers, authorities and individuals to examine evidence that would otherwise remain confined to providers’ statements. This is also a useful distinction when we consider how to trace responsibilities in cases involving platforms.
The question of algorithmic hegemony thus brings us back to the conditions in which we use these tools. They can broaden access to knowledge while concentrating the ability to set its rules in the hands of a few. The benefit does not erase this difference in power; recognising it allows us to ask for practicable alternatives, oversight and precise responsibilities.
The question running through the dossier is: who can guide the intelligence that helps us interpret the world? To answer it, we must be able to see and discuss the choices we encounter every day, even when they present themselves as simple features of a tool.
Read the full issue
The full dossier follows the path from Gramsci to recommendation systems and personal assistants, with the studies examined, primary sources and questions that remain open.
© 2026 Barbara Gattobigio · Gruppo Radar
Comprendere oggi. Costruire domani · by effettoantropico.life
All rights reserved on original content. Free access does not authorise reproduction or republication without consent, except as permitted by law. Third-party materials remain the property of their respective owners. To share this issue, use the link to the article.
Cover in focus

